Why we dont support Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage

In 2007, Responsible Travel began to look into Pinnewala Elephant Orphanage to find out if it really was an ethically-run sanctuary for orphaned elephants. Unfortunately, a report by the charity Born Free revealed that it had a very poor animal welfare record, and in 2008 we removed all trips featuring Pinnewala from our site. Read about our reasons below.

Home\Volunteer travel\Elephant conservation

Why we do not support Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage

Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage is one of Sri Lanka's most popular animal attractions. Although the conditions here are generally better than at some other establishments in the region, the welfare of the animals is a cause for concern for many experts.

We've put this page together to voice opinions on Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage, explain how we've dealt with various concerned parties and to raise travelers' awareness of the animal welfare issues.

See all our Elephant conservation Vacations

Give us a call

The issues

We started looking into Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage back in October 2007 when a member of staff at Responsible Travel became aware that the animal welfare standards there may be questionable. We approached our vacation companies in Asia for their opinions and started a discussion in house as well as online.

Many of our members believed that Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage, although not an ideal environment for the elephants, provided a safe haven for the animals. For us at Responsible Travel, the concern is that Pinnawala is advertised as an 'orphanage' or 'sanctuary' which implies that the animals are rescued and well cared for, when in reality the elephants are bred and displayed as a tourist attraction.

Pinnawala Elephant orphanage was the subject of a report by the animal welfare charity Born Free. Some of the key points in the report include male elephants chained during 'musth' (an aggressive period associated with reproductive hormones) causing wounds to the elephant's legs; the elephants are trained with the threat of pain from an 'ankus' (a shark hook with a spike, used as a traditional elephant training tool); and the elephants are used as photo props to bring in tourist revenues.

The role of sanctuary or orphanage conflicts with the stated policy of encouraging breeding at Pinnawala. Born Free does not support the keeping of animals in captivity unless it is for their own benefit.

– Born Free

The report goes onto explain that the terms 'orphanage' and 'sanctuary' should distinguish a captive animal facility from a zoo when the animals have been rescued from unacceptable captive conditions and are unable to be returned to the wild. The best interests of the animals should be a sanctuary's priority, not profit.

To breed more animals for the purpose of being kept in zoos, or sent to private collections or temples, clearly does not satisfy this requirement.

– Born Free

Our Elephant conservation Vacations

Our decision

The debate continued through the winter of 2007 during which time we sought the views of our tour operators and balanced these against Born Free's report:

"We take clients to the orphanage to encourage the orphanage not to deviate from their responsible policies. The more people (clients) we take to the orphanage, more the pressure and visibility on the orphanage on any shortcoming in their responsible policies. I think if tourists did not visit this place, the shortcomings would not have been revealed and the pressure wouldn't be there on the administration of the orphanage to get things right. As responsible individuals I think we must get together through our different roles to fix the problem than deserting the place and ignoring the short-comings by not visiting that place." – Concerned tour operator

In spring 2008 however, we came to the decision to remove all trips that included Pinnawala. We asked our tour operators in Asia to change their itineraries and asked them to consider encouraging their travelers to avoid Pinnawala. We suggested that our tour operators visited the Elephant Transit Home instead:

The Born Free Foundation supports the Elephant Transit Home (ETH) in Udawalawe, in Southern Sri Lanka. This facility takes in wild baby elephants that have been separated from their mothers, and cares for them until they can be returned to the wild. Although Pinnawala may not be able to return its animals to the wild, it could certainly provide them with a more natural life, as the protocols of ETH demonstrate.

– Born Free

The decision to exclude Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage from our site was not an easy one. Whilst we were certain that the animal welfare standards at the orphanage were not acceptable, the question of whether we were imposing our own, Western values overseas remained an issue. However our decision was made based on the Born Free report. The final trip was removed in August 2008.

"We recognise the report from Born Free and although the short term alternatives to Pinnawala are far from ideal, our belief is that this does not make it acceptable to visit and therefore condone their current practices. Born Free have identified an alternative destination for travelers who wish to see elephants in captivity - the Transit Home - which will also benefit from tourism."– Justin Francis, co-founder and Managing Director of Responsible Travel

More about Elephant conservation

Elephant trekking holidays - right or wrong?

Elephant trekking vacations - right or wrong?

It's long been a highlight of many vacations in Asia, but riding elephants could lead to the extinction of wild populations, and often involves cruelty to the animals in order to sustain it.

Elephant sanctuaries

The terminology surrounding elephant sanctuaries can be confusing, but we explain the differences between sanctuaries, orphanages and camps and discuss their ethics.

Culture & community

Asia has a long history of keeping elephants in captivity, to be used in wars, in the logging industry and now in tourism, and we ask what their role might look like in future.

Elephants back safaris & conservation

We explain why Responsible Travel no longer promotes elephant rides in sanctuaries or in national parks, based on recommendations by vacation companies and wildlife charities.

Facts & links

Did you know there are two species of elephants? Can you tell them apart? And did you know that elephants, can be right- or left-tusked? Read on for more elephant facts and useful links.

Wild elephant watching

Nothing beats seeing elephants in their natural habitat, whether that's in the jungle, savannah or desert. Our interactive map reveals where to encounter elephants in the wild.

Photos of elephants we hate

Performing elephants, chained elephants, ivory, zoos and howdahs all make for very sad images, which we really don't want on our memory cards after a vacation to Southeast Asia.

Elephant sanctuaries which we do & don’t support

Read our list of elephant sanctuaries we do and don't support, based on our comprehensive review of all the elephant sanctuaries featured on our site.

Elephants & tourism

Elephant trekking and captive elephants are complex issues. We spoke with vacation companies, wildlife charities and NGOs to help us form our stance on elephants and tourism.

More relevant guides

Written by Vicki Brown

Why we dont support Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage